Christmas at The Lucky Dill Deli is a time-honored tradition, and 2022 is no exception. We’ve taken extra steps to make it a great day for everyone.
Dine in on Christmas Eve
3-Course Christmas Eve Feast
Fabulous dessert options
Hot chocolate bar for lil dillers
***We Are Only Taking 750 Christmas Dinner Package Bookings, So Act Fast!***
Dine-In Dinner Preview
Main Entrees
Fresh Buttermilk-cranberry soda bread rolls for all diners
Feast of The Fishes Cioppino ala Little Italy
Fisherman’s Cioppino Seafood Stew | Shrimp | Mussels | Littleneck Clams | Cod | Scallops | A Rich Lobster Based,White Wine & San Marzano Tomato Broth| Ciabatta Toasts to Dip | Lemon
Homestyle Turkey Dinner with Fixins
Hand Carved Turkey Breast | Sweet Potato | Cornbread Stuffing | House Mashed | Winter Vegetable Medley| Turkey Gravy | Cranberry Sauce
Mile High Christmas Lasagna
Layer upon Layer of Bolognese Meat Sauce | Whipped Ricotta | Fresh Mozzarella | Romano & Parmesan | Fresh Herbs | Fire Roasted House Marinara, Garlic Ciabatta
Hand Carved N.Y.C. Black Angus Prime Rib
10 oz Certified Black Angus Prime Rib | Garlic & Herb Rub | Natural Herbed Au Jus | Horseradish Aioli | House Mashed Potatoes | Winter Vegetable Medley
Kings Cut Prime Rib
One Pound Prime Rib
Dessert Options
Price included with entree purchase
Caramel Granny Apple Pie w/ Whipped Cream
Buttery caramel and toffee-studded custard hug fresh Granny Smith apples piled high in our melt-in-the-mouth shortbread crust
NYC Cherry Cheesecake
Our New York Cheesecake smothered with dark sweet Bing cherries
Pumpkin Pie
Whipped Cream
Molten Chocolate Bundt
Our moist dark chocolate cake enrobed with dark chocolate filled with a melty dark chocolate truffle, crushed peppermint, whipped cream
Kids Menu
Rudolph Burger
Cheese Burger, All Decked Out Like Rudolph on Brioche, French Fries
A Trip to The Peppermint Hot Chocolate Bar
Straight from the North Pole topped off with marshmallows, whipped cream, chocolate sauce crushed peppermint and more
Black and White Cookie and Christmas Sweet Treats
The legendary New York cookie hand dipped in chocolate and vanilla icing, a Sweet Treat bag to take home
What You Get
Hand-Sliced Roast TURKEY
Cranberry SAUCE
Herbed STUFFING
Cranberry Challah Rolls
Mashed POTATOES
GREEN BEANS Amandine
Maple Glazed SWEET POTATOES
Creamed ONIONS
Customized Platter OF THANKSGIVING DESSERTS
Complimentary WINE
Got Questions?
We’ve Got Answers!
What if it rains?
Our tent is waterproof! 💪 Since Christmas is one of our busiest days, it’s going down rain or shine. But rest assured, we’ll keep you dry! ☔
What if I make a reservation and can’t make it?
We do require a reservation fee of $2.50 per person. This day is going to fill up fast, so if you need to cancel, the fee is non-refundable.